I'll never forget the first time I visited my friend, Trisha parents' house. There were horses everywhere: On the walls, on the towels, on the toilet seat and, of course, on the shelves. I almost fainted when I walked into the living room and saw what looked like a whole wall of Hagen-Renaker Amirs, Zaras and Zillas.
"Whoa!" I gasped. "Are those...?"
Trish knew where I was going and quickly cut me off. "No," she said matter of factly. "They're knock-offs. My grandma painted them a long time ago."
And for years, that's all I knew about those horses.
Now, thanks to Kristina Lucas and her excellent Muddy Hoofprints blog, I know a bit more.

In a post dated November 13, 2018, she writes: Decades ago, and for a very short time, a company called "Shirmar" made unglazed castings of several Hagen-Renaker Designer's Workshop molds, including large Zara. They were identical in size to HR's finished products because the HR foreman provided Shirmar with the HR molds, and his personal permission, to make them. This was done without consulting the Renakers, and they subsequently requested all the molds back. This explains why no generational size loss has been recorded in Shirmars; they were all first gen. Some were allegedly plaster castings, but some were cast in ceramic and fired to bisque. I have handled a Shirmar that was identified in one HR book as plaster, but it was actually bisque. Collector Laura Behning had a complete family set of Shirmar's renditions of Amir, Zara, and Zilla, and confirmed that they were hollow ceramic, not plaster.
Shirmar's castings were made for the hobby painting market, just as holiday-themed white bisque and plaster sculptures are sold today, by craft supply shops. However, a telltale sign of a bisque Shirmar is a huge, unplugged pour hole in the belly.
 |
| Amir's pour hole |
Last month, rather unexpectedly, I became the caretaker for most of the Brown/Welch Shirmar collection.There are a few Amirs,
a number of Zaras,and two Zillas.
Most of them aren't pristine. There are some broken - and in this case, missing - legs.
Also, a couple of the models have been attached to bases.
Trisha told me that this trophy used to have a Gladys Brown Edwards topper. Sadly, that broke so Marie replaced it with one of the Zaras.
The trophy itself was won by Mt View Charmalea in 1970.
Most of the Shirmars aren't dated, but this one - another Zara - is clearly marked 1973.Although the do very much resemble their HR relatives, these models are thicker, heavier and a little bit coarser.
They clean up nice, so a few are destined to be refinished.I've dreamed of owning a palomino Amir my entire life.Others will kept as is, in memory of Marie and Donna.Eventually, some will probably be re-homed. But not yet.
It's been almost forty years since I first saw these horses. For now, I'm happy having them on my shelves.