As long as there have been model horse shows, there have been accusations of judge misconduct in regards to pinning their friends' horses. While I have no doubt this has happened, I would argue that most of what people think they're seeing is... not that. In today's Sunday Soapbox guest post, Lesli Kathman tackles this topic head-on with a clear explanation of why judges do some of the things they do. Spoiler alert: It's not about giving ribbons to their friends.
Watching the Tables
by Lesli Kathman
So often when I read one of perennial "judges are awful" posts on social media, the "proof" offered is something that looks very different to someone who does a lot of judging. Here's a recent example, taken from the Modelholics Anonymous group. Someone said they knew cheating was happening because the judge watched people - "their friends" - bring horses up to the table.
As a judge, I watch my tables a lot. Many times, I am assessing whether or not I can double-load the other half. That's become so much more of a thing in recent years as we've broken the classes down more minutely and fewer horses enter each one. Double-loading means people aren't there all day, which goes a *long* way in making the show a better experience for everyone. The host won't get venue late fees. Entrants might have enough time and energy to grab dinner after the show. Distant showers might have time to drive home, or more daylight hours to do so safely.
I am also trying to catch horses in the wrong class. This is especially important now as breed lists have changed and there is some confusion. If I monitor things as they come up, I know who to give a heads-up if something needs to leave. That also means I am often glancing at tags and looking for the person who brought the horse.
Worse, I've even glanced at a tag, looked for an owner... and then not looked at the horse again. In these cases, the tag showed a major misunderstanding - i.e. British Spotted Ponies are *appaloosa* spotted, not pinto spotted - and I had more than six horses in the class so it wasn't going to place. No need to look further... but I did try to look to see who picked it up so I could let them know the problem was an easy fix. (Picking something, almost anything, else as a breed!)
My focus on the tables is about the logistics of the show, but more than anything, it's about trying to make sure people who came all that way for a day feel welcome and have a good time. I try to keep tabs on which entrants are in my division. I am alert to folks getting overwhelmed, because I will pause if the schedule permits. If I haven't laid down the ribbons, I let people bring a late entry. Whenever possible, I try to make my ring shower-friendly and shower-focused.
What I don't do is worry about whether being friendly with entrants or looking at the wrong thing will be misinterpreted. I trust that entrants who have questions will ask them, rather than assume the worst. Because, really, why would anyone spend a Saturday crouched down along a table, writing on a clipboard, if they didn't care about serving the hobby community?
Thank you, Lesli, for this detailed - and accurate - explanation of why a judge can and should watch their tables. I really hope this will help clear up some of the misconceptions that plague our community.